Duhan van der Merwe and Josh McKay absences explained as Scotland make 11 changes for Japan

Injury update on Sione Tuipulotu, Ben White, Jack Dempsey, Scott Cummings

Scotland’s team announcement for the Japan match generated as much interest in the players not selected as those picked to play on Saturday.

There is no place in the match-day 23 for Josh McKay who was expected to make his debut after fulfilling the five-year residency qualification this week.

Also absent is Duhan van der Merwe, the only fit back in Gregor Townsend’s original 37-man Nations Championship squad who will not feature in the autumn pool-stage games.

Duhan van der Merwe during a Scotland training session at Oriam, in Edinburgh.placeholder image
Duhan van der Merwe during a Scotland training session at Oriam, in Edinburgh. | SNS Group / SRU

Some senior players have been rested, with Finn Russell, Kyle Steyn, Huw Jones and Ewan Ashman all given the chance to recharge their batteries for Finals Weekend at Twickenham.

11 changes to the Scotland team which beat Australia 15-12

And then there is the lengthy injury list which at the start of the week featured captain Sione Tuipulotu, Ben White, Jack Dempsey, Scott Cummings, Fergus Burke and Alex Craig and was extended on Thursday to include Pierre Schoeman and Josh Bayliss.

It goes some way to explaining why Gregor Townsend has made 11 changes to the team which beat Australia 15-12 at Murrayfield on Sunday, with Ollie Smith, Stafford McDowall, Rory Hutchinson, Kyle Rowe, Jamie Dobie, Nathan McBeth, Gregor Hiddleston, Jonny Gray, Max Williamson, Liam McConnell and Ollie Leatherbarrow all coming into the starting side.

The Japan game allows the head coach to run the rule over a number of fringe players as he looks ahead to the 2027 Rugby World Cup which will require him to pick a squad of just 33. It’s under a year until the tournament kicks off in Australia.

It was slightly surprising, therefore, that McKay will not be involved this weekend. Speaking after the Australia game, Townsend had said that the Glasgow Warriors full-back would be “one of the ones competing to start” but it will be his club-mate Ollie Smith who will wear 15 against Japan.

Josh McKay has been training with Scotland but is not in the squad to face Japan.placeholder image
Josh McKay has been training with Scotland but is not in the squad to face Japan. | SNS Group / SRU

Townsend hasn’t ruled out New Zealand-born McKay playing in Finals Weekend at Twickenham when Scotland are likely to play either Argentina or Australia.

Josh McKay is in the mix for next week

“We know we have one more game and Josh could be involved next week but if he's not then it wouldn't change what we think of him and wouldn't change, I hope, his motivations to get into a Six Nations squad and a World Cup squad,” said Townsend.

“We've seen how well he's trained with us, it'll be up to him to put pressure on selection during the period between now and the Six Nations, but he's in the mix for next week.”

The future does perhaps not look so rosy for van der Merwe, Scotland’s second top try-scorer of all time. This is the fourth Test window in a row that the Edinburgh winger has found himself down the pecking order.

Duhan van der Merwe ‘has to put the work in’

With 35 tries in 54 Scotland appearances, van der Merwe had been a nailed-on starter but, at 31 and after a number of injury issues, that is no longer the case. Darcy Graham and Rowe will start on the wings against Japan, with Kyle Steyn and Dobie having been the first-choice wide men at the start of the autumn campaign.

“He knows he has to put the work in,” Townsend said of van der Merwe. “I think he has to have a bit of luck as well. He had injuries coming into this year. I thought he finished the season really well with Edinburgh. He played well in our game against Fiji.

“He just hasn't had a run of games with Edinburgh this year. He picked up an injury in our training. What we're seeing from him this week in particular is someone who is highly motivated to give back to the team and, at his best, he's one of the best wingers in the world.”

Injury prognosis on Sione Tuipulotu, Jack Dempsey and others

Gruelling matches against the All Blacks and the Wallabies have taken their toll and Townsend praised Dempsey for “playing through the pain” to help Scotland win the latter game. It appears to have come at a cost, however, with the Toshiba Brave Lupus No 8 undergoing surgery on Thursday on a foot injury, meaning he will miss the start of the new Japanese season

“Jack got operated on today so obviously he will be working with his club on that,” said Townsend. “It's great that he's been able to have the surgery in Scotland and also very good that he's been operated on so quickly and that he can make a quicker recovery.

“He was playing through pain at the weekend. I thought he was one of our best players. He was so determined to play against Australia. He knew his game against New Zealand hadn't gone as well as he'd hoped. But he was excellent during the time he was on with the work he got through, his ball carrying, his defence, it really helped us win.”

Dempsey would have been unavailable for the Six Nations in any case, following his move to Japan, but that will be of little comfort to his new club.

There was a better prognosis for Tuipulotu, who pulled out before the Australia game due to a knee injury. Townsend said the centre and the other injured players should all be available for the Six Nations.

“Sione got good news,” said Townsend. “He flew down to see a specialist on Monday in London, so [he should be fit to return in] three or four weeks. We're thinking Ben White's about the same timescale.

“Scott Cummings might be slightly longer and Fergus Burke is similar. Alex Craig had a hip issue and he didn't train fully leading up to New Zealand. Then he came back and trained fully last week but it flared up again. So again that might be just two or three weeks.”

Scotland v Japan teams for Murrayfield

Nations Championship, Saturday, 2.10pm

Scotland: 15. Ollie Smith; 14. Darcy Graham, 13. Stafford McDowall, 12. Rory Hutchinson, 11. Kyle Rowe; 10. Tom Jordan, 9. Jamie Dobie; 1. Nathan McBeth, 2. Gregor Hiddleston, 3. Zander Fagerson, 4. Jonny Gray, 5. Max Williamson, 6. Liam McConnell, 7. Rory Darge (capt), 8. Ollie Leatherbarrow. Replacements: 16. Seb Stephen, 17. Rory Sutherland, 18. Will Hurd, 19. Gregor Brown, 20. Magnus Bradbury, 21. Matt Fagerson, 22. George Horne, 23. Blair Kinghorn.

Japan: 15 Takuro Matsunaga; 14 Kazuma Ueda, 13 Jisu Lee, 12 Charlie Lawrence, 11 Jone Naikabula; 10 Shinya Komura, 9 Naoto Saito; 1 Sojiro Otsuka, 2 Kenji Sato, 3 Ryosuke Iwaihara, 4 Jack Cornelsen 5 Warner Dearns (capt), 6 Ben Gunter, 7 Kanji Shimokawa, 8 Faulua Makisi. Replacements: 16 Mamoru Harada, 17 Yota Kamimori, 18 Taufa Latu, 19 Michael Stolberg, 20 Ruan Botha, 21 Tiennan Costley, 22 Shinobu Fujiwara, 23 Riku Kitahara.

Comments

 0 comments

Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.

Dare to be Honest
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice