How 100s of journeys via Edinburgh Airport have left me with unhealthily strong views – Alistair Carmichael
Alistair Carmichael MP is better placed than many to cast judgment on Edinburgh Airport
When people think of Scotland they generally imagine heather-clad moors, windswept Munros or the history-laden stonework of Edinburgh Castle.
When people first come to Scotland, however, their first sight is often the vinyl-clad corridors and fluorescent striplights of Edinburgh Airport. When people choose Scotland for a new adventure I am not sure that half an hour trekking towards baggage reclaim is quite what they have in mind.
Edinburgh Airport is Scotland’s first impression on the world – and it isn’t pretty. So when The Scotsman launched its “Fit to Fly” series looking at Edinburgh Airport and its development plans, my interest was piqued.
READ MORE: 'Flying home to Scotland via Edinburgh Airport is a deeply depressing experience' – Henry McLeish


Sumburgh and Kirkwall set the standards
The airport is now undergoing a £500 million, five-year expansion programme called “Terminal Transformation” (I will, with some difficulty, refrain from making any jokes about the double meaning of the word “terminal”). That redevelopment is not before time.
As someone who generally passes through Edinburgh Airport twice a week when parliament is sitting, I feel I am fairly well-placed to comment on its qualities, or lack thereof. After 25 years representing Orkney and Shetland in Westminster, the quality of airport provision is a subject on which I have strong views (some might say unhealthily strong).
For the record, obviously my “favourite airport” list is topped by Sumburgh and Kirkwall in the Northern Isles. They are followed (in the UK) by London City and Inverness. Space precludes me saying much about international airports except that if you really want to raise my blood pressure, drop the subject of Schiphol into conversation.
My top tips for travelling through Edinburgh
I may as a result be slightly more sensitive to Edinburgh’s flaws as a transport hub than others – but when we are talking about a capital city’s flagship airport, standards ought to be set pretty high to begin with.
Generally I like airports that are functional. Lounges are handy if there is a delay but for the most part unnecessary. Not walking miles to get to a departure gate is a box worth ticking.
My top tip as a frequent flyer through Edinburgh: never rush to baggage reclaim. However slowly you saunter, you will still have a wait when you get there. Equally, if Edinburgh is a staging post towards a final destination (say Orkney or Shetland), don’t check in a bag – unless you can afford to wait three or four days to be reunited with it.
I am told that the airport is currently making a major effort to turn planes around within a time target. Doing this while taking a bag off one plane and putting it onto another seems to be a further challenge.
Benign efficiency should be the goal
Insofar as Edinburgh has a saving grace, it is that other airports in Scotland largely follow the same formula. It is only when you look further afield that you start to realise how far behind the game our capital’s airport really is.
We do not have to try to emulate the heady airport standards of Singapore and Dubai but it would do no harm to aim for a mildly pleasant atmosphere – or at least benign efficiency.
Now is the time for a proper refresh of Scotland’s front door to the world – so that the imagination of travellers and tourists is finally met by reality.
Alistair Carmichael is the Scottish Liberal Democrat MP for Orkney and Shetland
Comments
Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.