How The Scotsman’s Fit to Fly? series gave disgruntled Edinburgh Airport passengers a voice – Alastair Dalton

Readers congratulated The Scotsman on highlighting problems at Scotland’s busiest air terminal

I vividly recall Edinburgh Airport announcing its first route to New York – one of its first long-haul links – more than 20 years ago.

I was invited to a breakfast meeting at its then owner BAA Scotland’s grand offices in Drumsheugh Gardens in the west end of Edinburgh, and remember how significant and exciting a development it was for what was then a relatively small operation.

Since then, the airport has more than doubled its passenger numbers and expects to handle a new record of nearly 18 million this year, with routes stretching from Canada to China, including three to Middle East hubs – and now up to four flights a day to New York on four different airlines.

The air traffic control tower which opened in 2005 has become a symbol of Edinburgh Airport. Picture: Lisa Fergusonplaceholder image
The air traffic control tower which opened in 2005 has become a symbol of Edinburgh Airport. Picture: Lisa Ferguson | The Scotsman

Edinburgh has grown from being in the long-time dominant Glasgow Airport’s shadow to eclipse its west coast rival with now more than twice as many passengers. It has even ditched its slogan “Where Scotland Meets the World” because it says it’s now achieved that.

By any measure, the airport has been a massive success story, and I have chronicled that expansion over the last two decades. However, it’s not my job as a journalist to be a cheerleader for anything in transport.

Sure, I will report what I regard objectively as significant successes, and express my views in opinion columns like this one, but I have never hesitated from writing stories about what I believe are valid deficiencies or concerns.

News by its nature is the abnormal – such as the unusual, the very good and the very bad. An organisation operating normally and performing as it should is not news.

A few transport operators – and unfortunately they are the exception – realise there will always be both positive and negative stories about them, and take criticism, where it is evidenced based, on the chin.

The flip side to Edinburgh Airport’s impressive growth has been increasing concerns from passengers about the ability of it and its partners, such as Border Force and the airlines’ baggage handling firms, to cope.

The airport has denied that its attitude to such criticism has been ‘nothing to do with us’ – because problems such as passport queues and luggage delays lie with these other bodies – but that has been some people’s perception.

The Scotsman’s Fit to Fly? series examined the state of Edinburgh Airportplaceholder image
The Scotsman’s Fit to Fly? series examined the state of Edinburgh Airport | Gavin Munro/The Scotsman

Similarly, the airport attempted to downplay past concerns about the state of its worn-out runway, despite a freedom of information response from its regulator, the Civil Aviation Authority, revealing that it had been closed 16 times in a year for emergency patching, disrupting nearly 100 flights and thousands of passengers.

The groundswell of unease about the passenger experience at the airport – especially for arrivals – prompted The Scotsman’s Fit to Fly? series last week.

But days before it was launched, and despite extensive contact with the airport, including to arrange a right of reply, a leaked letter from its new chief executive Mark Johnston, which was reported elsewhere, admitted: “There are areas of the operation where improvement is required.”

In it, he expressed concern about “aspects of the arrivals experience and the impact this is having on passengers” including baggage delays.

Significantly, Mr Johnston said while that was a shared responsibility among several organisations, such a distinction was not apparent to most passengers, and the situation “reflects on Edinburgh Airport as a whole, impacting all of our reputations, but particularly that of the airport”. I don’t recall the airport saying that so explicitly before, and I welcome his frankness.

Our Fit to Fly? series sought to be a fair reflection of the state of the passenger terminal and a fair assessment of its unprecedented £500 million expansion that is underway.

That included commentary pieces by both the airport and Scottish Passenger Agents Association to balance critical ones by former First Minister Henry McLeish and Scottish Financial Enterprise chief executive Sandy Begbie.

We also asked you, our readers, what you thought. I had low expectations of how many would respond, but was very pleased that 400 completed our survey by the end of last week, which has now topped 450.

The results of what I clearly referred to as a straw poll were clear – two thirds gave the airport four out of ten or less, and a similar proportion thought things had got worse over the last five years.

I’m not suggesting that the same proportion of all the airport’s passengers would say the same – although they might – but as a snapshot, it demonstrated that a not insignificant number of people had taken the trouble to voice their disquiet.

In fact, during the week, while several readers got in touch to congratulate The Scotsman for raising the issue, I recall just one person being critical. They described our focus on Edinburgh Airport as “bordering on obsession”, having previously accused me of unbalanced reporting.

However, I’m not picking on the airport, but shining a spotlight on it because, from the information I receive, it is experiencing difficulties that I simply haven’t heard are happening at Glasgow or other Scottish airports. If you know otherwise, please get in touch, by emailing me at [email protected]

Every time over the last few years that The Scotsman has reported on passenger complaints – often on incidents affecting large numbers of travellers – the airport has pointed to the high ratings in its passenger satisfaction surveys.

However, it has yet to be so frank about how such responses are gathered. It has said only that some were sourced from a survey offered when passengers log on to the airport wifi.

But what officials would not say is what proportion of these came from arriving passengers – I’m guessing departing passengers are more likely to log on – and why that survey does not contain any questions about arrivals or baggage reclaim.

Comments

 0 comments

Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.

Dare to be Honest
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice