Andy Burnham’s attempt to save our young generation could be his greatest achievement – Brian Wilson

The wide-ranging reforms proposed in Alan Milburn’s report on young people who are not in education, employment or training will need to overcome resistance within the system if they are to succeed

Alan Milburn launched his final report on young people not in employment, education or training (Neets) earlier this week. Picture: Stefan Rousseauplaceholder image
Alan Milburn launched his final report on young people not in employment, education or training (Neets) earlier this week. Picture: Stefan Rousseau | PA

Alan Milburn’s report, “From a Welfare State to a Working State”, is a very long essay in common sense. Indeed, it is difficult to recognise any ideological premise from which its conclusions would be opposed.

Nobody disputes (except in Scotland) a problem inherent in huge numbers of young people not being in education, employment or training. In Scotland, that equates to one-in-six 16 to 21-year-olds at which point, for some reason, we stop counting. In England, it’s about one in eight 16 to 24-year-olds.

Of course, numbers are not distributed evenly. There are not many rich “neets” whereas Pat McFadden, the Work and Pensions Secretary, cited a recent visit to the DWP office in Bellshill where 40 per cent of young people were on health benefits “or on the way to claiming them”. Take your pick. Deny or address.

Partisan ‘row’ about cutting benefits

These problems driving these statistics took decades to develop and our old friend, common sense, suggests they will take time to reverse. There is plenty to blame the Tories for but the thrust of Milburn’s report is not to reduce it to party politics. The emergence of “youth detachment” – not just unemployment - is a societal phenomenon and an international one at that.

At present we are not good at dealing with it or acknowledging its complexity. Other countries do it better and we should learn from them, as Milburn advises. His report certainly deserves better than a partisan ‘row’ about cutting benefits as if this was some kind of elixir nobody had thought of.

Yet at Prime Minister’s Questions, Kemi Badenoch, could not rise above “when are you going to cut the welfare bill?” and a soundbite that “those young people are not going to be young in ten years’ time”. No, but others will be and, if left untackled, the social damage and costs will be ten times worse. Thinking Tories might agree.

On the simplistic demand to cut benefits, Milburn’s report responds: “Crude benefit cuts will not work. If young people are plunged into destitution, costs to the taxpayer simply show up elsewhere in the system – in homelessness, health and crime. What is needed instead is upfront investment in more opportunities for young people to earn or learn… Investment first, payback later.”

Some in Labour’s ranks are equally eager to reduce the debate to an argument about benefits, in order to protect them, apparently under all circumstances. In Scotland, we’re told, this is enshrined as a human right. If so, a life on benefits seems a very odd one.

Young people want to work

The principal victims of “youth detachment” are young people themselves even if not all of them recognise it at the time. Research for Milburn’s report suggests that more than seven out of ten say they want to work. The duty of the state, and certainly of a Labour government, is to enable that ambition to be fulfilled – not to condemn those who are capable of more to a life on benefits as any sort of ‘right’.

Sometimes, that involves Labour recognising its own mistakes and Milburn does not shrink from doing so. Incentives, rather than disincentives, are required for employers to give ‘neets’ a chance.

The Scottish government should embrace working with the rest of the UK to deliver these objectives. In the half-empty glass, Barnett consequentials from social security might reduce; in the half-full one, there will be productive areas of funding to advance the agenda, in which Scotland will share and many young Scots will benefit. Common sense.

Milburn goes out his way not to blame young people themselves. “Fundamentally,” he writes, “the ‘neet’ crisis is a moral problem, with dire economic and fiscal consequences.” The moral dimension arises from the fact young lives are being wasted and human potential denied, by a system that doesn’t work.

He goes further. “The system is not a system at all. Responsibility is fragmented between institutions, programmes and tiers of government. Education, health and welfare operate in separate silos and magnify the very problem they are supposed to help solve.”

Anyone who has been near government, or on the receiving end of it, recognises the truth of that statement. Silos are the curse of good government, with departmental territory jealously guarded by mandarins and ministers at the expense of the greater good.

Determination to see it through

By recognising in plain language that this culture must be challenged, ruthlessly and consistently over a period of years, Milburn is setting a high bar. That too will need time and determination from the top of government to see it through. Otherwise, take my word for it, the silos and their guardians will prevail.

For example, Milburn writes, very sensibly: “The aim over the next decade should be an integrated age 14-to-19 framework bringing academic and vocational learning into a single structure… The long-term direction should give greater parity to different forms of achievement and recognise the full range of knowledge, skills and experience young people need.”

For decades, lip service has been paid, not least in Scotland, to parity of esteem for vocational education through FE colleges. It has never come within a mile of happening because ‘the system’ elevates universities and looks down its nose at the sector which produces work-ready young people. Change that imbalance alone and you change a lot.

My only concern about Alan Milburn’s report is that it is so wide-ranging and counter-cultural to many whose interests depend on maintaining the status quo that its focus may become lost in the sands of time and obstruction.

On the other hand, it could inspire the most consequential reforms of the Burnham era and transform opportunities for the next generation. The verdict that matters will not be delivered in Whitehall or Holyrood but in Bellshill and places like it, a decade from now.

Related topics:

Comments

 0 comments

Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.

Dare to be Honest
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice