SNP government should ‘take Milburn Report seriously’, says UK government

Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden (Maja Smiejkowska/PA)placeholder image
Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden (Maja Smiejkowska/PA)

Pat McFadden said that youth unemployment “is a problem in Scotland” and told the SNP to “make sure that personalised local support is available” to young Scots.

The SNP must take the milestone Milburn Report on youth unemployment “seriously” in Scotland because one in six under-25s north of the Border neither earn nor learn, a UK government minister has warned.

Pat McFadden, Secretary of State for Work and Pensions, said that youth unemployment “is a problem in Scotland” and told the SNP to “make sure that personalised local support is available” to young Scots.

The Glaswegian was speaking in the House of Commons following the publication of the UK government-commissioned report, carried out by former Labour health secretary Alan Milburn, on Tuesday.

The report called for billions of taxpayers’ money to be spent to create opportunities for those under 25 to get off benefits and into work.

But many of the measures will only apply in Scotland if the Scottish Government implements them, because education, skills, health and local government are devolved to Holyrood.

Responding to a question from Labour MP Joani Reid about the commitments he will seek from the Scottish Government, Mr McFadden said: “My honourable friend is absolutely right to say that this is a problem throughout the United Kingdom, that no part of the United Kingdom can look at itself and say we do not have a problem here.

“The Prime Minister and the Chancellor and I attended a meeting with the Scottish and Welsh First Ministers in Glasgow a couple of weeks ago, where this was a top item on the agenda.

“And it's really important that governments in all parts of the country take this seriously.

“Obviously, localised delivery will mean things can be tailored for local circumstances. That's the intention of it.

“But this is a problem in Scotland, and in Wales, and in England.

“And we hope that the Scottish and Welsh governments will take it seriously and make sure that personalised local support that I'm speaking of is available to young people throughout the UK.”

Scottish Secretary Douglas Alexander said “far too many young people are missing out” with around in one in six young Scots - around 90,000 people - currently not in work, education or training.

He added: “The Prime Minister has been clear that it would be an economic catastrophe and a moral failure to stand by and watch a generation of young people be left behind. Tackling this crisis is a top priority for the UK Government.”

The report calls for the Government to spend around £5.8 billion a year by 2036-37, funding a new youth opportunity service and support, including tax breaks and bonuses for firms employing young people.

The cost would be offset by £3.6 billion of annual welfare savings and £2.4 billion of extra tax revenue from people in work.

The review proposes replacing the health-related aspect of benefits for 16-24-year-olds with a new youth allowance, which would provide every young person a legal entitlement to a route into education, training or work, and a guarantee of support to get the health, employment and functional and practical help they need to get into and stay in work.

SNP Education Secretary Mairi McAllan said the Scottish Government was already delivering on the measures in the report.

Ms McAllan said: “Where there is opportunity to collaborate with the UK Government and others for the benefit of young people in Scotland, we will take it. However, many of the reforms it recommends for England – including stronger vocational curriculum and qualifications, tracking of young people’s activity and joined up support wrapped around them to help them participate – reflect approaches Scotland has already embedded over many years.

“This year our schools saw increased academic attainment as well as a 121 per cent increase since 2019 in awards in practical subjects like construction, childcare and personal finance – subjects which are preparing our young people for the world of work.

“I welcome the report’s recognition that the institutional answer will differ in Scotland and that each devolved government should consider how its principles fit existing services.

“Alan Milburn’s interim report notes there are around 40 per cent of 16-to 19-year olds starting an apprenticeship, compared with around 20 per cent of 16-to 18-year olds in England.

“In Scotland, 95.7 per cent of school leavers are in a positive destination three months after leaving school, the joint second highest on record. For 16-24 year olds, the employment rate is higher in Scotland than in England, and the majority of our economically inactive young people are students.”

“While any action to support young disabled people into work is welcome, it must not come at the expense of essential support. Any changes to UK Government disability benefits or employment support spending could have significant knock-on effects for Scotland's people and budget so we expect to be consulted on any further reforms.”

Paisley born Mr McFadden, who represents a constituency in England, also accused the SNP of “reflecting Tory propaganda” after a Nationalist MP said youth unemployment was “a direct consequence of [Labour’s] stagnating economy.”

Arbroath and Broughty Ferry MP Lara Bird said: “We welcome many of the recommendations in this review, especially as so many of the calls are already embedded in Scotland. However, it does let the Labour Party off the hook for their own economic record.

“Now, we want to see the welfare bill come down, but the idea that the number of young people out of work is because they are unmotivated or lazy is just fantasy.

“Instead, they have been failed by a Labour government that has increased the job taxes and has overseen a catastrophic decline in vacancies.”

Mr McFadden hit back: “Perhaps I shouldn't be surprised to hear the SNP reflecting Tory propaganda.

“And if she wants to argue that things are perfect in Scotland, she should speak to the area manager of the Bellshill Job Centre, who last Christmas told me that more than 40 per cent of the youth cohort were on the health journey.

“Action is needed throughout the United Kingdom, not just in one part of the country.

“And as for young people, she can't have been listening to my statement because I said very clearly: they're not snowflakes, they're not shirkers. We believe in them. We want a better future for them.”

A person is on a health journey at a job centre when they are claiming health-related benefits.

Comments

 0 comments

Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.

Dare to be Honest
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice