Rassie Erasmus ‘shines a light’ on rugby’s big problem, says Scotland great

Confusion and frustration reigns due to constant tinkering with laws

Jim Hamilton has always been his own man and he is not joining the rush to condemn Rassie Erasmus.

The former Scotland lock believes the outspoken South Africa coach is “shining a light” on important issues in rugby and also raising the sport’s profile.

In a crowded market where football dominates, Erasmus has managed to catapult rugby into the spotlight this week.

Rassie Erasmus, the South Africa head coach, prior to the Nations Championship match with France in Paris.placeholder image
Rassie Erasmus, the South Africa head coach, prior to the Nations Championship match with France in Paris. | Getty Images

News of his six-game ban for the now infamous “match-fixing” comments made big waves, with the story leading the back pages of the Times, Telegraph and Guardian.

Erasmus’ outburst was beyond the pale for many. By questioning whether officiating during South Africa’s defeat by France amounted to match-fixing, the Springboks coach “impugned the integrity” of the match officials, with match referee Andrea Piardi and television match official (TMO) Matteo Liperini in the firing line.

‘Rassie Erasmus has fallen on his sword for the better of the game’

Hamilton can see a bigger picture and believes Erasmus’ remarks might serve a greater purpose by highlighting the seemingly never ending tinkering with rugby’s laws which does little to attract the casual fan and complicates matters even for the most committed.

“The referee is central, literally central, to a lot of decisions that go on in the game,” Hamilton told The Scotsman. “And unfortunately, we've lost our way in rugby when it comes to how that's all managed. It's different for different competitions, different iterations, different interpretations, different nationalities, constant ever-moving of different laws. It's kind of come to a head now, hasn't it?

“Erasmus has fallen on his sword for probably the better of the game. I don't agree with slagging off referees personally. I don't think he has done that with Piardi.

“He's obviously danced around the conversation a little bit. And he's talking more about the structures that are in place as opposed to calling out the referee specifically. He's talking about having use of the TMO and not utilising that.

“And that's been a shift, right? Because we saw 12 months ago we were heavily reliant on the TMO. And it's that ever-changing, constant evolution and they might call it innovation around the laws.

“We've added in a new law, which is the knee drop [and hip drop] tackle on November 1. And we're seeing a load more than we used to. The irony is that we didn't really notice them before.”

Jim Hamilton, a rugby ambassador for Boyle Sports, believes Rassie Erasmus raised some important points.placeholder image
Jim Hamilton, a rugby ambassador for Boyle Sports, believes Rassie Erasmus raised some important points. | SPORTSFILE

Erasmus claimed France had committed 17 illegal hip-drop tackles which went unnoticed by the on-field officials and questioned whether the failure to intervene could amount to “match-fixing” or “manipulation of the game or result”.

The perception this autumn is that TMOs have been less inclined to intervene. Erasmus certainly thinks so and, combined with new laws on ‘hip drop’ and ‘knee drop’ tackles, Hamilton can understand his frustration.

‘Frustration and confusion about the direction of our game’

“Did he do it correctly? Probably not,” said Hamilton, who won 63 caps. “There was probably one sentence too many in there that has got him into trouble. But he's shining a light on something that is incredibly frustrating as a player.

“And I know the players really well. I know the referees, some of them really well. And there's a real frustration and a real confusion about the direction of our game and who's controlling it.

“Why does it constantly keep changing? And, you know, Rassie Erasmus is the guy. Whether you like him or not, he said what he said. And everything was right up until one sentence where he was probably a little bit close to the bone and he's been punished accordingly.”

Erasmus won’t be allowed in the Aviva Stadium on Saturday but the Ireland v South Africa match will have the eyes of the world on it. Hamilton is pleased that the Nations Championship is being screened in this country on ITV because he understands the value of terrestrial television. He just wishes World Rugby would stop tinkering.

The casual fan won’t know what’s going on

“I mean, your casual fan probably doesn't really know what's going on,” said Hamilton, who will be at Murrayfield on Saturday for Scotland v Japan.

“I imagine over half of the people watching on ITV probably wouldn't know anyway. They'd be looking at it and it would be foreign to them. And that's an issue in itself.

“The fact that the game's already difficult to control and to narrate and to commentate and to bring in new audiences, that then there's a new law being brought in across the board on November 1.

“But, you know, I look at it as drama sells. Whether people like that or not, everyone's talking about this today and they'll be talking about it tomorrow."

Jim Hamilton teamed up with BOYLE Sports to discuss the Nations Championship. When your Rugby Union team goes 17 points ahead, BOYLE Sports pays out. 18+ BeGambleAware

Comments

 0 comments

Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.

Dare to be Honest
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice