Health secretary - I still have confidence in NHS Grampian bosses

Health Secretary Angela Constance said she was only made aware of the bombshell allegations against NHS Grampian when they were made public to the media yesterday.

Health Secretary Angela Constance has said she still has full confidence in NHS Grampian’s chief executive, despite claims that serious failings have led to multiple deaths.

Ms Constance also revealed she was only made aware of the shocking allegations when they were made public to the media yesterday.

On Thursday Dr Mohammed Habib from Aberdeen Royal Infirmary called for criminal charges to be brought against the health board and his lawyer Aamer Anwar dubbed the hospital a “slaughterhouse”.

Lawyer Aamer Anwar and whistleblowing surgeon Dr Mohammed Habibplaceholder image
Lawyer Aamer Anwar and whistleblowing surgeon Dr Mohammed Habib | John Devlin/The Scotsman

Dr Habib said he had been raising issues with senior NHS bosses and government ministers for a decade, but was repeatedly ignored.

The surgeon has put forward a number of actions he believes should now be taken, including sacking NHS Grampian’s chief executive Laura Skaith-Knight.

However, when asked whether she still has confidence in the chief executive by BBC Radio Scotland Breakfast, the health secretary said: “I do, because the history of some of the very distressing issues predate her appointment.”

When asked when she first learned of Mr Habib’s claims, she said: “So I found out yesterday, that was the first time I had seen his correspondence.”

Dr Habib claims he has written to the government on several occasions, including to First Minister John Swinney, former first minister Humza Yousaf, and former health secretaries Michael Matheson and Neil Gray.

When asked how she did not learn of this sooner, Ms Constance said: “It is current practice that where individuals write in with detailed questions that are specific around clinical questions, that would go to the appropriate team.

“It’s also important to highlight again that the First Minister has asked the permanent secretary to review our internal processes to see if any changes need to take place.”

She added: “The reality is, we didn’t see that correspondence. As health secretary, I would always expect issues around patient safety to be raised directly with me.”

In a damning report published last week, NHS Grampian’s leadership was highly criticised and there were details of one death caused by mismanagement. However, Dr Habib says there was an unpublished report in 2022 which highlighted 19 deaths.

When asked if NHS Grampian will be allowed to mark its own homework when it comes to investigating these 19 deaths, Ms Constance said: “In the first instance I want to continue my discussions with NHS Grampian around the very legitimate questions around why this 2022 report was not published.”

Health Secretary Jane Barlowplaceholder image
Health Secretary Jane Barlow | Jane Barlow/Press Association

On Thursday, Dr Habib told a press conference: “These cases relating to ARI are, I believe, due to poor decision making, poor technique and recklessness, and they are tantamount to corporate homicide.

“In all the cases that I reported, they were in my opinion guilty of wicked recklessness and an indifference to patient death as an outcome.

“NHS Grampian knew enough to have stopped this carnage.”

Mr Anwar said: “He is fully aware that he may lose his career for whistleblowing and may be targeted, but he has taken this step today because 36 years ago, on becoming a doctor, he was taught that taking care of patients must be his first concern.

“Catastrophically, the operating theatre he worked in at times could be described as a slaughterhouse, which killed through incompetence and negligence, whilst not giving a damn for accountability.”

Comments

 0 comments

Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.

Dare to be Honest
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice