A lack of experience isn’t same as a lack of ability
Skills shortage is a leadership challenge, not just a recruitment problem, writes Peter Proud
If employers keep demanding experience without providing opportunities to gain it, where do we expect the next generation of talent to come from?


Scotland’s skills shortage is a leadership challenge, not simply a recruitment problem. Before asking government, universities or colleges to act, employers must ask: what are we doing to fix it?
Competing for the same pool of experienced people will not create the workforce Scotland needs. Building that workforce means recognising potential, investing in it and giving people the chance to prove themselves.


Giving someone that first opportunity means accepting that they are not the finished article. The employer’s job is to help them get there.
I am proud of Forrit’s apprenticeship programme, where we have invested in apprenticeships for nearly a decade.
This is not a corporate social responsibility exercise or a slogan on a wall, it is part of how we build our business and contribute to our industry.
We recruit people who have gained a Higher National Diploma (HND) at college, allowing them to enter the third year of their degree through our Graduate Apprenticeship scheme. Each week, they spend four days working and one studying at Napier University.
They are paid employees doing real work, with support and time for their studies. Work and learning go hand in hand and an apprenticeship is an investment, not a source of cheap labour.
Our apprentices typically start in quality assurance before progressing into web development, cybersecurity or IT. Testing gives them immediate responsibility, with experienced colleagues to guide them. As we say, a lack of experience is not a lack of ability.
As of October 2026, 24 of our apprentices have graduated, 19 with First Class Honours and five with 2:1s. I am proud of those results, and behind every qualification is someone who was given a chance to discover what they could achieve.
That chance should not depend on having followed the neatest route through education. A CV is a record of someone’s past, not a blueprint for their future. If we recruit only people whose journey looks familiar, we should not be surprised when we miss talent, curiosity and fresh thinking.
Learning goes both ways. Apprentices challenge familiar assumptions, while mentoring makes experienced colleagues reconsider how they work and why. Explaining something is a useful test of whether you understand it yourself.
Some of our apprentices have moved on to other Scottish technology employers. I consider that a success, not a failed investment. Their skills have not been lost to Scotland. We cannot champion a stronger technology sector while measuring the value of training solely by whether someone remains on our own payroll.
Stop waiting for the perfect candidate. Give people meaningful work, time to learn and support. Back what they could become, not just what they can do today. We cannot keep asking where the skilled people are without helping create them.
Scotland’s future talent is not somebody else’s responsibility, it is for all of us.
Peter Proud, Founder and CEO, Forrit
Comments
Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.