Theatre reviews: The 39 Steps | The Last Laugh
Two very different productions both tap into our shared cultural past in search of laughs, writes Joyce McMillan
The 39 Steps, Pitlochry Festival Theatre ★★★
The Last Laugh, Theatre Royal ★★★★
In a world where credible futures seem in increasingly short supply, it sometimes seems as if cultural nostalgia is becoming our only jam. Rock music survivors from the 20th century stage ever-larger stadium tours, tribute musicals whisk us back to the 1960s or 70s; and here, in Pitlochry and Glasgow this week, are two stage shows which have their own special relationship with our cultural past.
Patrick Barlow’s brisk two-hour stage adaptation of The 39 Steps - first seen in London two decades ago - is probably best understood not as a version of John Buchan’s 1915 novel, but as an affectionate send-up of Alfred Hitchcock’s hugely successful 1935 film, designed to extract maximum laughs from the absurdities of extreme fringe theatre, as a cast of only four try to tell a story featuring at least 20 characters, with much help from bad hats, and worse facial hair.
READ MORE: The Nature of Forgetting: 'dream-like exploration of the mind' returns to the Edinburgh Fringe
To judge by Barlow’s programme note for this year’s Pitlochry production, he also intended his adaptation to add a little heart to what began as a brusquely masculine tale of Richard Hannay, a British imperial adventurer at a loose end, who finds himself in a desperate race to expose a deadly network of foreign spies before they catch up with him. And in Ben Occhipinti’s Pitlochry production of Barlow’s version - which follows and surpasses Hitchcock in introducing some female love interest to the story - Alexander Service as a handsome Hannay, and Blythe Jandoo in stylish Thirties form as all the women with whom he falls in love, both bring a real touch of romance to their performances.
The problem, though, is that almost all other aspects of the plot are reduced to such Monty Python-style absurdity - as supporting actors Chris Coxon and Stephanie Cremona conjure up a bewildering series of dastardly villains and spoof Scottish peasants - that it becomes very difficult to attach any real meaning to the story. Liz Cooke’s set is charming, with its little train circling the front of the stage to the upbeat strains of Vivian Ellis’s Coronation Scot.
To my eyes, though, most of the comedy looks laboured and un-funny, in a post-1980s fringe theatre style that has had its day; and despite the best efforts of the actors - who received a well-deserved cheer from the audience as they took their bows - the show seems to me to lack momentum, and to be both less meaningful, and less seriously funny, than Barlow originally intended.
There’s a richer and more direct vein of comedy, by contrast, in writer and director Paul Henry’s 80-minute play The Last Laugh, now on a UK-wide tour after its 2024 Edinburgh Fringe success. The show features a dressing-room conversation among three of Britain’s most revered 20th century comedy stars; the great natural comedians Tommy Cooper and Eric Morecambe, and Bob Monkhouse, comedian and game-show host, who spent most of his life studying the structure of comedy.
The Last Laugh follows other fine plays about comedy - notably Tom McGrath’s Laurel & Hardy - in dealing with the strange, poignant relationship between comedy and death. Both Cooper and Morecambe died in mid-career, in the spring of 1984; and Hendy uses this fact to place all three stars in what turns out to be a dressing room on the edge of eternity.
For most of its length, though, the show is a funny and fascinating exploration of comedy itself, as delivered by a generation of absolute masters. Damian Williams as Tommy, Bob Golding as Eric, and Simon Cartwright as Bob all make a brilliant job of evoking the special style and comic energy of the men they play; and they also bring an immense quiet skill to their handling of the play’s huge range of emotional registers, from the daftly hilarious to the poignant, and finally to the tragic.
The 39 Steps is in repertoire at Pitlochry Festival Theatre until 26 September; The Last Laugh is at the Theatre Royal, Glasgow, until 19 July
Comments
Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.